Tag: review

NY Daily News & Toonzone – Season Finale Reviews

Derpy Launch Watch by Shutterflye

A couple of season finale reviews have cropped up in the past 24 hours—all these guys who got that fancy press package that some people have drooled over.

Our first review comes from David Hinckley of the NY Daily News, who gave the episodes in general a 3 out of 5. He is pretty positive about it, and explains of course the unusual crowd of adult fans behind it. All in all, he says it’s good. You can read that article here.

Then we have Maxie Zeus from Toonzone. This review I’d call 50/50, as it’s not overly positive nor negative (in my opinion). The article starts off more or less stating that the reviewer knows very little about MLP. It makes no mention about the community behind it. They call the script generic, but most of us know that tends to be the case sometimes, claiming that the script could be used for any cartoon. Either way, you can read this article over here on Toonzone. (Ironic, a site called Toonzone knows nothing about a cartoon…)

[Sources: NYDaily: The Round Stable | Toonzone: RGB]

Community Wednesdays #03 – Bronyville #49, Everfree Radio & SFWeekly Review

Bronyville 049 – Friendship Background Pony

Dear Princess Celestia,
I’m writing this letter seeking out your help. My poor cousin AJ seems to get a bad rap this week and I wanted to see if you could do anything to help the 3rd best pony stand out. Perhaps a festive hat or a goodwill balloon ride? After that’s handled you can listen to our show this week which features Mr. Poniator and our usual Midnight Shadow. We talk about the basics of flash, a ton of upcoming international pony merch, and the plight that has befallen Twist!

Apple Cider

Download – Original Article – Show Notes

Episode Review

EverFree Radio released their review of MMMystery on the Friendship Express full of reference analyses and Twilight Sparkle in a hat. Also released is a review of the fanfic A Game of Twits by Cassius, featuring guest reviewer Andrew J Talon, author of Progress.

Listen in and stay tuned, because EverFree Radio has a lot of awesome things lined up for you all in the coming months. Things that will blow your minds. Many of them coming from their programs. So keep a watchful eye on their Programming page!

Episode Review: http://everfreeradio.com/?p=3314
Fanfic Review: http://everfreeradio.com/?p=3273
Programming Page: http://everfreeradio.com/?page_id=1390

Radiant Eclipse

Radiant Eclipse is an in-depth, segment-based talkshow produced by the creators of Equestrian Tides exclusively for EverFree Radio! Tune in every Sunday for the show, and visit the program page and their blog for more information on the awesome people who run it!

Every Sunday @ 14:00 CDT

EFR Post

PREMIERE: Equestria Inquirer Today!

Equestria Inquirer is a news program that will bring the hard-hitting stories, from the revelations of Twilight’s anti-union magic policies to the continuing conflict of Rainbow Dash’s declaration as a Weapon of Mass Destruction and her defiance of the Equestrian Armed Forces. Their new videos will premiere weekly on EFR’s livestream (while chatting live on the IRC!), and they will release the videos on Youtube and newspaper articles on their DeviantArt afterwards!

Visit their program page for more information!

Every Wednesday @ 19:00 CDT

Season 1 Reviews

Season 1 – Episode 19 & 20 Review

My Little Pony: FiM S1 Reviews by Sherilyn Connelly

Review: German Audio Plays and DVDs

Photo by Kadji

Photo by Kadji

“You need to stop, reading these old dusty books… Find new friends!” That’s what Princess Celestia told Twilight Sparkle. Even though she is he smartest unicorn in Equestria, her grade in Friendship is an F. There is more to a young pony’s life than studying. So Twilight Sparkle is on her way to Ponyville to meet five very unique ponies: Pinkie Pie, Rainbow Dash, Rarity, Fluttershy, and Applejack.

The blurbs on the freshly released My Little Pony DVDs and CDs just summarize vaguely the plot of the pilot episode. However this can’t stop an interested viewer from putting the disc in his DVD or CD player. While every DVD contains three episodes in chronological order, the CDs were cut to two.

Click for our CD and DVD Raffle

Click for our CD and DVD Raffle

Let us start with the audio play. Like most audio plays for cartoon series, dialogs from the show were directly copied onto the CD, accompanied by a narrator. Due to this narrator, you can enjoy the episodes in a very new way. Why, you ask? Some child audio play narrators have the habit to be sarcastic in some situations and sometimes “argue” with the characters in the story. Here, the narrator likes to make fun out of Rainbow Dash and also Spike (e.g., “magisches Briefkastenmaul” (magicial mailbox maw)). Nevertheless, the quality of the audio is a lot better than the TV version and on top of that, the songs made by Daniel Ingram got hugely improved in terms of sound quality. Sadly, only two episodes are on each disc, despite the fact that only half of the CD was used.

The DVDs are a different matter. Filled with three episodes and no extras, the average price of about €8 is too much for some. Also, due to license issues, only the German dub is on the disc. However, the picture and audio quality is better than the TV version but looks gray-washed compared to the iTunes version. The audio desync of the TV version was fixed, and it is interesting that EDEL used the original text display and not the German one. Furthermore, the DVD presents the show in 5.1 Dolby Digital sound and 576p 16:9. To sum up: The DVD is not perfect, like other ones for children. But if EDEL can fix the dubbing license issue, add extras like behind-the-scenes or the extended opening, the German DVDs should be the choice for everypony—especially since they are regio free.

I know some of you hate the German dub, and weirdly enough most of you are German, since other European viewers are envious of our localization quality. Remember that Hasbro went in our direction with the DVD and even re-synched some parts of the show to make them fit the older audience. So leave your high horse and enjoy some little pony fun. The audio play is something you can always enjoy, thanks to the narrator; the DVD is in its current state arguable, I must confess, but like in every economy, requests can change company decisions. If you want to support the show, buy it, if you want to experience the dub first before doing so, watch it legally on nick.de.

And now for those who want a final score:

Audio play: 9/10

DVD: 7/10

Content sheet:

CD 1: “A mission from Princess Celestia Part 1” / “A mission from Princess Celestia Part 2”
CD 2: “It’s hard for a friend” / “Applebucking harvest”

DVD 1: “A mission from Princess Celestia Part 1” / “A mission from Princess Celestia Part 2” / “It’s hard for a friend”
DVD 2: “Applebucking harvest” / “Gilda, the party stopper” / “Show-off Trixie”